The definition of Huntington’s Disease used by the Social Security Administration is so outdated it causes many to be denied disability coverage the first time. According to the SSA, Huntington’s is simply a movement disorder. This definition does not take into account those that have issues with memory and thinking processes or behavioral or other psychological problems. And since each person’s progression in the disease is totally different, the person seeking disability may not even have the physical symptoms until the final stages when they have already lost the ability to process normal thoughts and actions. As a result of this incomplete definition of the disease, many are denied disability coverage.
My brother in law, Bill, is one of them. Physically, he does appear to be fine. He does occasionally have some trouble walking and maybe a little bit of difficulty swallowing; his real symptoms are more cognitive. His memory is unreliable. He has a hard time following through in some thought processes. For example, if he wants to cross the street, he simply starts walking across the street. His brain has trouble processing that he needs to make sure to check for any cars coming before he starts to cross the street. He is also affected mentally and emotionally as well. He is easily agitated and can lash out in anger or burst out crying for no real reason. Obviously, these are not physical issues.
For the several months, we have been working to get him approved for disability so that we can set up in a home of some kind, but it is not going well. In the first round, he has already been denied. Basically because the SSA believes there is no physical reason that he cannot work. And based on the SSA’s definition of the disease, that would make sense. He has no physical symptoms, so he must not have the disease is pretty much what they think. This has to change. The definition of Huntington’s Disease used by the SSA needs to change to cover all symptoms and make it easier for families to obtain disability when a loved one is no longer able to work and provide for themselves or their family.
Right now, there is a bill before Congress that will redefine the definition of Huntington’s Disease called the Huntington's Disease Parity Act. This bill changes the definition to include the other symptoms of the disease and not just the movement disorder that it was first defined as. In addition, this bill will also waive the current 24 month waiting period before someone can be covered by Medicare. For people such as my brother-in-law, this is very important. Currently, he is not being treated with any of the medications that are available to help minimize his symptoms. And, if he was approved for Disability today, he wouldn’t be able to purchase insurance and still be able to pay for a place to stay. Plus, he needs some of the medicines that they prescribe to Huntington’s patients today so that he might be around in two years when Medicare would kick in. But, if he can’t pay for it, how can he get the medications to survive the next two years? Of course, all of this hinges on whether or not he is considered incapable of working given his current status within the disease. He is not, but the Social Security Administration believes otherwise, leaving him to either live on the streets or be a burden on family members that are struggling in their own way with the disease.
I know we all have our own views about Social Security Disability and if it is the responsibility of the government to care for those who are incapable of caring for themselves for whatever reason. I am not asking you to do something that you might be against, but I do ask that you at least consider contacting your Representatives and Senators to encourage passage of this bill. First, it will help to raise awareness of Huntington’s Disease and the many ways it effects the roughly 30,000 people diagnosed, their families, and the roughly 250,000 that are at risk for developing this disease. In addition, passage of this bill will help to provide the necessary medical treatments much earlier than before for people such as my brother in law, who is single, unable to work and could not afford the cost of health insurance if he was to be approved for disability. Please consider contacting your House of Representatives (https://writerep.house.gov/writerep/welcome.shtml) or your Senators (http://www.senate.gov/reference/common/faq/How_to_contact_senators.htm) to encourage passage of The Huntington's Disease Parity Act.
You can read the details of the bill at http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h112-718
Thank you for your help and support!
My husband has Huntington's Disease. He inherited it from his mother who we lost in 2010 to the disease. He has a brother and a sister that have been diagnosed with the disease. He also has cousins that are living with the disease. This is our story of how we live with this disease.
Friday, April 15, 2011
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
How Will This Show Tell the Story?
Most television shows that mention Huntington’s Disease only do so in passing. Few really take the time to make it a major storyline. In fact, the number of show that have made it a true part of the story can probably be counted on one hand. So, I was very surprised when I sat down to watch an episode of Private Practice. Okay, so I am a bit behind. I have only just now sat down to watch and episode of Private Practice that aired a few weeks ago and had a Huntington’s Disease story line. Part of the summary is that a friend of one of the doctors threatens to kill herself if she test positive for the Huntington gene. I have to admit, that ticked me off. Why would a person do that? However, after watching the episode, I have to say they did a fairly good job of giving a bit of insight into the disease and what in can lead to. Essentially, after having recently buried her mother due to the Huntington’s Disease, Michelle debates getting tested. She says that if she test positive, she is going to kill herself because she doesn’t want to live life the way her mother did. Seriously? So, one of the doctors (Amelia) convinces Michelle to get tested and then lies about the results saying that Michelle does not have the gene when she really does. And all of a sudden Michelle’s world can go on. I wanted to throw something at the TV at this point in the whole storyline. Amelia thinks she is helping Michelle by allowing her to think that she doesn’t have the gene so she can go on living. While I admit that as the disease begins to take control of a person’s body, the outcome is not pleasant. However, should a person stop living today because of something that most likely won’t happen for many years down the road? In the end, Amelia felt guilty and came clean with Michelle letting her know the truth of the test results. Michelle is devastated and debates if she wants to end her life. Amelia finally convinces her that she needs to live for today and not worry about what will happen down the road. She doesn’t have any of the effects of the disease today and may not for many years to come. For all they know, Michelle might die in a car accident tomorrow but that doesn’t mean she stops leaving her apartment. And Amelia convinces Michelle that life does go on and that as a friend – who happens to be a doctor – she will be with Michelle every step of the way. Now the part where Amelia hints that she would be willing to help Michelle end her life when the disease begins to take control is a subject to discuss in another blog. I do have to give kudos to the show. They did a good job of describing some of the physical side effects that the disease can have on a person, but they took it a step farther. They took time to highlight the effects on the disease on family members as well as the personal struggle each person has as the decide whether or not to take that step to be tested. Not many shows have taken the time to do that. Thanks Private Practice for allowing everyone to view a small window into the lives of those that deal with this every day. If you want to check out the show, here is a link. http://abc.go.com/watch/private-practice/SH559070/VD55117689/love-and-lies
Friday, March 11, 2011
What About Adoption
So many people often ask why we haven’t considered adoption as an alternative. It is a great way to allow us to love a child and provide a better life for them than they have now. Plus, there is not a risk of passing on a genetic condition to a child that is not naturally ours. Honestly, we have looked into, talked about it, prayed about and spent many hours thinking about whether it is the best option for us. We have come to the conclusion that it is. We have been discouraged by the research we did that found going through the state will most likely not work. Even though Robert is currently not experiencing any serious symptoms of the disease, the state still does not consider us a good option. They do not like to place a child with a family that has a diagnosed life threatening medical condition. So, that leaves the private adoption route. We looked into this as well. One drawback is the huge expense we would have to pay for it, but that was not the real reason we decided not to adopt. The real reason has to do more with the time the entire process would take and Robert’s life expectancy. Even though he is currently not experience any major symptoms, he will. Based on genetic history of his family, the doctors figure that he will most likely begin to show more pronounced symptoms in his early 60’s. That is about 20 years or so from now. Since the adoption process can be long and drawn out, it might be another five years before we are chosen to be adoptive parents. That means that Robert would only have 15 years with the child, and the child would only have his or her father around for 15 years or so. Robert grew up with a very absentee father to begin with. Plus, his father died when Robert was in his 20’s, so he knows what is like to lose a parent at such a young age, too. Knowing his own health condition, Robert does not want to force his own child to go through what he had to. Plus, he had a hard time watching his mother slowly progress through the disease the last few years and he is much older. To be a teenager and have to watch your father go through the same thing is not something he wants to force on his own child.
In the end, we have counteracted our desire to have kids by helping out at our church and loving on the many nieces and nephews that our families have blessed us with. In addition, he does have a step-daughter from his first marriage that he considers his own and we spend time with her as well. Plus, since we can’t seem to agree on how to raise our dog, we probably wouldn’t be able to agree on how to raise a child either.
In the end, we have counteracted our desire to have kids by helping out at our church and loving on the many nieces and nephews that our families have blessed us with. In addition, he does have a step-daughter from his first marriage that he considers his own and we spend time with her as well. Plus, since we can’t seem to agree on how to raise our dog, we probably wouldn’t be able to agree on how to raise a child either.
Sunday, February 13, 2011
To Have or Not to Have
If you knew that by having a child, you could be handing them a death sentence, would you do it? If there was a 50/50 chance, would you be willing to take the risk? If you knew that there was a way that you could almost guarantee your child not be born with the same disease that has inflicted you, would you be willing to do something that goes against everything you believe in?
These are the question that Robert and I struggled with even before we got engaged. We wanted to have children. We like that idea of that tangible proof of our love for each other. On the other hand, we weren’t sure that we wanted to subject our children to the grief and pain that Robert faced with his mother. It was a gut wrenching decision.
One thing that I found out was if we chose to do in vitro fertilization, there was a way to minimize the risk of our child contracting HD. Prior to insemination, a test would be done on the embryos to determine if they had the HD mutation. Any embryos that were determined to have the genetic mutation would be discarded. At first, we thought that was an option, but the more we thought about it, the more we struggled with it. Deciding which embryos to keep and which ones to get rid of because they did not did not have a genetic mutation was playing God. We were taking the decision out of our Maker’s hands and that was not up to us to decide.
In the end, we decided to rely completely on God. If it was part of His plans for us to have children, then we would. If He decided that that was not what was in store for us, then that was the way it was to be. If we had a child that was born with the abnormality on her chromosome, then that is the way it was supposed to be.
We spent a year and a half trying for a child and in the end, it didn’t happen. In the course of trying, it was determined that I had some health issues that would not be easily overcome without risk to me and any child that I might have. In the end, it was taken out of our hands. That doesn’t mean that we don’t feel some moments of sadness or regret that we were not able to have a child, but we know that this life is the life that God has planned for us.
Someone else facing the choices we did may come to a different conclusion. For them, that is the choice that is the best for them. I do not judge them for the choices they make. I do understand it is not an easy choice and each couple has to make the decision that is best for them.
These are the question that Robert and I struggled with even before we got engaged. We wanted to have children. We like that idea of that tangible proof of our love for each other. On the other hand, we weren’t sure that we wanted to subject our children to the grief and pain that Robert faced with his mother. It was a gut wrenching decision.
One thing that I found out was if we chose to do in vitro fertilization, there was a way to minimize the risk of our child contracting HD. Prior to insemination, a test would be done on the embryos to determine if they had the HD mutation. Any embryos that were determined to have the genetic mutation would be discarded. At first, we thought that was an option, but the more we thought about it, the more we struggled with it. Deciding which embryos to keep and which ones to get rid of because they did not did not have a genetic mutation was playing God. We were taking the decision out of our Maker’s hands and that was not up to us to decide.
In the end, we decided to rely completely on God. If it was part of His plans for us to have children, then we would. If He decided that that was not what was in store for us, then that was the way it was to be. If we had a child that was born with the abnormality on her chromosome, then that is the way it was supposed to be.
We spent a year and a half trying for a child and in the end, it didn’t happen. In the course of trying, it was determined that I had some health issues that would not be easily overcome without risk to me and any child that I might have. In the end, it was taken out of our hands. That doesn’t mean that we don’t feel some moments of sadness or regret that we were not able to have a child, but we know that this life is the life that God has planned for us.
Someone else facing the choices we did may come to a different conclusion. For them, that is the choice that is the best for them. I do not judge them for the choices they make. I do understand it is not an easy choice and each couple has to make the decision that is best for them.
What is Huntington's Disease?
What exactly is Huntington's disease or HD? The shortened definition is that it is degeneration of specific brain cells that causes uncontrolled movements, loss of intellectual facilities and emotional disturbances. It also impacts the area of the brain that controls thought, perception and memory.
Long version is that HD is the result of an abnormality on the 4th chromosome that causes it to have an abnormal repeat. Over time, this build up of the abnormal repeat is what will cause the disease to overtake the body. There is no set age of when it will affect a person. It all depends on how fast the chromosome repeats itself and builds up in the body. However, most often, though, it begins during middle age. There are some people that have developed symptoms at an earlier age, but those are very limited numbers.
Huntington's disease is an inherited disease. It is passed on from an infected parent. Each child has a 50/50 chance of contracting the disease. An example of the randomness of who will be affected can be explained by using the example of my husband, Robert's family. His grandfather on his mother's side had the disease. Of the three children he had, only Robert's mother was infected. Robert's uncle and aunt did not inherit HD. Robert has 4 siblings. A sister and 3 brothers. Of the 5, his sister, one brother and Robert have tested positive. The other 2 brothers did not inherit the disease.
Long version is that HD is the result of an abnormality on the 4th chromosome that causes it to have an abnormal repeat. Over time, this build up of the abnormal repeat is what will cause the disease to overtake the body. There is no set age of when it will affect a person. It all depends on how fast the chromosome repeats itself and builds up in the body. However, most often, though, it begins during middle age. There are some people that have developed symptoms at an earlier age, but those are very limited numbers.
Huntington's disease is an inherited disease. It is passed on from an infected parent. Each child has a 50/50 chance of contracting the disease. An example of the randomness of who will be affected can be explained by using the example of my husband, Robert's family. His grandfather on his mother's side had the disease. Of the three children he had, only Robert's mother was infected. Robert's uncle and aunt did not inherit HD. Robert has 4 siblings. A sister and 3 brothers. Of the 5, his sister, one brother and Robert have tested positive. The other 2 brothers did not inherit the disease.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)